[lc_ctrl] Use unique diversification values

This makes the diversification values fed to the keymgr
unique for each group of life cycle states.

Fixes #14047

Signed-off-by: Michael Schaffner <[email protected]>

hw/ip/lc_ctrl/data/lc_ctrl.hjson

@@ -72,28 +72,40 @@
     },
     // Random netlist constants
     { name:      "RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid",
-      desc:      "Compile-time random bits for lc state group diversification value",
+      desc:      "Diversification value used for all invalid life cycle states.",
       type:      "lc_ctrl_pkg::lc_keymgr_div_t",
       randcount: "128",
-      randtype:  "data",
+      randtype:  "data", // Compile-time random bits
     }
-    { name:      "RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma",
-      desc:      "Compile-time random bits for lc state group diversification value",
+    { name:      "RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked",
+      desc:      "Diversification value used for the TEST_UNLOCKED* life cycle states.",
       type:      "lc_ctrl_pkg::lc_keymgr_div_t",
       randcount: "128",
-      randtype:  "data",
+      randtype:  "data", // Compile-time random bits
+    }
+    { name:      "RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev",
+      desc:      "Diversification value used for the DEV life cycle state.",
+      type:      "lc_ctrl_pkg::lc_keymgr_div_t",
+      randcount: "128",
+      randtype:  "data", // Compile-time random bits
     }
     { name:      "RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction",
-      desc:      "Compile-time random bits for lc state group diversification value",
+      desc:      "Diversification value used for the PROD/PROD_END life cycle states.",
+      type:      "lc_ctrl_pkg::lc_keymgr_div_t",
+      randcount: "128",
+      randtype:  "data", // Compile-time random bits
+    }
+    { name:      "RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma",
+      desc:      "Diversification value used for the RMA life cycle state.",
       type:      "lc_ctrl_pkg::lc_keymgr_div_t",
       randcount: "128",
-      randtype:  "data",
+      randtype:  "data", // Compile-time random bits
     }
     { name:      "RndCnstInvalidTokens",
       desc:      "Compile-time random bits used for invalid tokens in the token mux",
       type:      "lc_ctrl_pkg::lc_token_mux_t",
       randcount: "1024",
-      randtype:  "data",
+      randtype:  "data", // Compile-time random bits
     }
     // Hardware revision, meant to be overridden at the top-level
     { name:    "SiliconCreatorIdWidth",

hw/ip/lc_ctrl/doc/interfaces.md

@@ -4,13 +4,15 @@
 
 Note that parameters prefixed with `RndCnst` are random netlist constants that need to be regenerated via topgen before the tapeout (typically by the silicon creator).
 
-Parameter                      | Default (Max)         | Top Earlgrey   | Description
--------------------------------|-----------------------|----------------|---------------
-`AlertAsyncOn`                 | 2'b11                 | 2'b11          |
-`IdcodeValue`                  | `32'h00000001`        | `32'h00000001` | Idcode for the LC JTAG TAP.
-`RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid`    | (see RTL)             | (see RTL)      | Life cycle state group diversification value for keymgr.
-`RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma` | (see RTL)             | (see RTL)      | Life cycle state group diversification value for keymgr.
-`RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction` | (see RTL)             | (see RTL)      | Life cycle state group diversification value for keymgr.
+Parameter                        | Default (Max)  | Top Earlgrey   | Description
+---------------------------------|----------------|----------------|---------------
+`AlertAsyncOn`                   | 2'b11          | 2'b11          |
+`IdcodeValue`                    | `32'h00000001` | `32'h00000001` | Idcode for the LC JTAG TAP.
+`RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid`      | (see RTL)      | (see RTL)      | Diversification value used for all invalid life cycle states.
+`RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked` | (see RTL)      | (see RTL)      | Diversification value used for the TEST_UNLOCKED* life cycle states.
+`RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev`          | (see RTL)      | (see RTL)      | Diversification value used for the DEV life cycle state.
+`RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction`   | (see RTL)      | (see RTL)      | Diversification value used for the PROD/PROD_END life cycle states.
+`RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma`          | (see RTL)      | (see RTL)      | Diversification value used for the RMA life cycle state.
 
 ### Signals
 
@@ -182,11 +184,13 @@ For all signals except ESCALATE_EN, it is recommended to structure the design su
 The `lc_keymgr_div_o` signal is a 128bit diversification constant that is output to the key manager once the life cycle controller has initialized, and is asserted at the same time as `lc_keymgr_en_o`.
 Depending on which group the life cycle state is in, this signal is assigned a different random netlist constant as defined in the table below.
 
-Life Cycle State Group     | Assigned Diversification Constant
----------------------------|----------------------------------
-TEST_UNLOCKED\*, DEV, RMA  | `LcKeymgrDivTestDevRma`
-PROD, PROD_END             | `LcKeymgrDivProduction`
-All Other States           | `LcKeymgrDivInvalid`
+Life Cycle State Group | Assigned Diversification Constant
+-----------------------|----------------------------------
+TEST_UNLOCKED\*        | `RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked`
+DEV                    | `RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev`
+PROD, PROD_END         | `RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction`
+RMA                    | `RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma`
+All Other States       | `RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid`
 
 Note that this signal is quasistatic.
 It is hence recommended to place a max-delay constraint on it and leverage the synchronized version of `lc_keymgr_en_o` to enable any downstream register in different clock domains than the life cycle controller.

hw/ip/lc_ctrl/dv/env/lc_ctrl_parameters_cfg.sv

@@ -5,20 +5,43 @@
 class lc_ctrl_parameters_cfg extends uvm_object;
   // LC_CTRL parameters
   // Enable asynchronous transitions on alerts.
-  logic           [NUM_ALERTS-1:0] alert_async_on          = {NUM_ALERTS{1'b1}};
+  logic           [NUM_ALERTS-1:0] alert_async_on           = {NUM_ALERTS{1'b1}};
   // Idcode value for the JTAG.
-  logic           [          31:0] id_code_value           = 32'h00000001;
+  logic           [          31:0] id_code_value            = 32'h00000001;
   // Random netlist constants
-  lc_keymgr_div_t                  keymgr_div_invalid      = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(0);
-  lc_keymgr_div_t                  keymgr_div_test_dev_rma = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(1);
-  lc_keymgr_div_t                  keymgr_div_production   = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(2);
+  lc_keymgr_div_t                  keymgr_div_invalid       = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(0);
+  lc_keymgr_div_t                  keymgr_div_test_unlocked = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(1);
+  lc_keymgr_div_t                  keymgr_div_dev           = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(2);
+  lc_keymgr_div_t                  keymgr_div_production    = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(3);
+  lc_keymgr_div_t                  keymgr_div_rma           = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(4);
   `uvm_object_utils_begin(lc_ctrl_parameters_cfg)
     `uvm_field_int(alert_async_on, UVM_DEFAULT)
     `uvm_field_int(id_code_value, UVM_DEFAULT)
     `uvm_field_int(keymgr_div_invalid, UVM_DEFAULT)
-    `uvm_field_int(keymgr_div_test_dev_rma, UVM_DEFAULT)
+    `uvm_field_int(keymgr_div_test_unlocked, UVM_DEFAULT)
+    `uvm_field_int(keymgr_div_dev, UVM_DEFAULT)
     `uvm_field_int(keymgr_div_production, UVM_DEFAULT)
+    `uvm_field_int(keymgr_div_rma, UVM_DEFAULT)
   `uvm_object_utils_end
 
   `uvm_object_new
+
+  virtual function lc_keymgr_div_t get_exp_div(dec_lc_state_e state);
+    unique case (state)
+      DecLcStTestUnlocked0,
+      DecLcStTestUnlocked1,
+      DecLcStTestUnlocked2,
+      DecLcStTestUnlocked3,
+      DecLcStTestUnlocked4,
+      DecLcStTestUnlocked5,
+      DecLcStTestUnlocked6,
+      DecLcStTestUnlocked7: return this.keymgr_div_test_unlocked;
+      DecLcStDev:           return this.keymgr_div_dev;
+      DecLcStProd,
+      DecLcStProdEnd:       return this.keymgr_div_production;
+      DecLcStRma:           return this.keymgr_div_rma;
+      default:              return this.keymgr_div_invalid;
+    endcase
+  endfunction
+
 endclass : lc_ctrl_parameters_cfg

hw/ip/lc_ctrl/dv/env/lc_ctrl_scoreboard.sv

@@ -65,8 +65,9 @@ class lc_ctrl_scoreboard extends cip_base_scoreboard #(
     forever begin
       @(posedge cfg.pwr_lc_vif.pins[LcPwrDoneRsp] && cfg.en_scb) begin
         dec_lc_state_e lc_state = dec_lc_state(lc_state_e'(cfg.lc_ctrl_vif.otp_i.state));
-        lc_outputs_t   exp_lc_o = EXP_LC_OUTPUTS[int'(lc_state)];
-        string         err_msg = $sformatf("LC_St %0s", lc_state.name);
+        lc_outputs_t    exp_lc_o = EXP_LC_OUTPUTS[int'(lc_state)];
+        lc_keymgr_div_t exp_div_o = cfg.parameters_cfg.get_exp_div(lc_state);
+        string          err_msg = $sformatf("LC_St %0s", lc_state.name);
         cfg.clk_rst_vif.wait_n_clks(1);
 
         // lc_creator_seed_sw_rw_en_o is ON only when device has NOT been personalized or RMA state
@@ -87,14 +88,16 @@ class lc_ctrl_scoreboard extends cip_base_scoreboard #(
 
         if (cfg.escalate_injected) begin
           exp_lc_o = EXP_LC_OUTPUTS[int'(DecLcStEscalate)];
+          exp_div_o = cfg.parameters_cfg.keymgr_div_invalid;
         end
 
         fork
           begin
             // Delay a some of cycles to allow escalate to be recognised
             if (cfg.escalate_injected) cfg.clk_rst_vif.wait_clks(5);
             ->check_lc_output_ev;
-            check_lc_outputs(exp_lc_o, {$sformatf("Called from line: %0d, ", `__LINE__), err_msg});
+            check_lc_outputs(exp_lc_o, exp_div_o,
+                             {$sformatf("Called from line: %0d, ", `__LINE__), err_msg});
           end
         join_none
 
@@ -230,6 +233,7 @@ class lc_ctrl_scoreboard extends cip_base_scoreboard #(
 
   // check lc outputs, default all off
   virtual function void check_lc_outputs(lc_outputs_t exp_o = '{default: lc_ctrl_pkg::Off},
+                                         lc_keymgr_div_t exp_div_o = '0,
                                          string msg = "expect all output OFF");
     `DV_CHECK_EQ(cfg.lc_ctrl_vif.lc_dft_en_o, exp_o.lc_dft_en_o, msg)
     `DV_CHECK_EQ(cfg.lc_ctrl_vif.lc_nvm_debug_en_o, exp_o.lc_nvm_debug_en_o, msg)
@@ -243,18 +247,20 @@ class lc_ctrl_scoreboard extends cip_base_scoreboard #(
     `DV_CHECK_EQ(cfg.lc_ctrl_vif.lc_seed_hw_rd_en_o, exp_o.lc_seed_hw_rd_en_o, msg)
     `DV_CHECK_EQ(cfg.lc_ctrl_vif.lc_creator_seed_sw_rw_en_o, exp_o.lc_creator_seed_sw_rw_en_o, msg)
     `DV_CHECK_EQ(cfg.lc_ctrl_vif.clk_byp_req_o, exp_clk_byp_req, msg)
+    `DV_CHECK_EQ(cfg.lc_ctrl_vif.keymgr_div_o, exp_div_o, msg)
   endfunction
 
   virtual task process_tl_access(tl_seq_item item, tl_channels_e channel, string ral_name);
-    uvm_reg        csr;
-    bit            do_read_check = 1'b0;
-    bit            write = item.is_write();
-    uvm_reg_addr_t csr_addr = cfg.ral_models[ral_name].get_word_aligned_addr(item.a_addr);
-    lc_outputs_t   exp = '{default: lc_ctrl_pkg::Off};
-    bit            addr_phase_read = (!write && channel == AddrChannel);
-    bit            addr_phase_write = (write && channel == AddrChannel);
-    bit            data_phase_read = (!write && channel == DataChannel);
-    bit            data_phase_write = (write && channel == DataChannel);
+    uvm_reg         csr;
+    bit             do_read_check = 1'b0;
+    bit             write = item.is_write();
+    uvm_reg_addr_t  csr_addr = cfg.ral_models[ral_name].get_word_aligned_addr(item.a_addr);
+    lc_outputs_t    exp = '{default: lc_ctrl_pkg::Off};
+    lc_keymgr_div_t exp_div = cfg.parameters_cfg.keymgr_div_invalid;
+    bit             addr_phase_read = (!write && channel == AddrChannel);
+    bit             addr_phase_write = (write && channel == AddrChannel);
+    bit             data_phase_read = (!write && channel == DataChannel);
+    bit             data_phase_write = (write && channel == DataChannel);
 
     // if access was to a valid csr, get the csr handle
     if (csr_addr inside {cfg.ral_models[ral_name].csr_addrs}) begin
@@ -403,7 +409,7 @@ class lc_ctrl_scoreboard extends cip_base_scoreboard #(
           begin
             // Wait for escalate to be recognise
             if (cfg.err_inj.security_escalation_err) cfg.clk_rst_vif.wait_clks(5);
-            check_lc_outputs(exp, $sformatf("Called from line: %0d", `__LINE__));
+            check_lc_outputs(exp, exp_div, $sformatf("Called from line: %0d", `__LINE__));
           end
         join_none
       end

hw/ip/lc_ctrl/dv/tb.sv

@@ -22,10 +22,14 @@ module tb;
   // Random netlist constants
   parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid    =
     LcKeymgrDivWidth'({(LcKeymgrDivWidth/8){32'h00000000}});
-  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma =
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked =
     LcKeymgrDivWidth'({(LcKeymgrDivWidth/8){8'h5a}});
-  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction =
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev =
     LcKeymgrDivWidth'({(LcKeymgrDivWidth/8){8'ha5}});
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction =
+    LcKeymgrDivWidth'({(LcKeymgrDivWidth/8){8'h69}});
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma =
+    LcKeymgrDivWidth'({(LcKeymgrDivWidth/8){8'h96}});
 
   // macro includes
   `include "uvm_macros.svh"
@@ -95,8 +99,10 @@ module tb;
     .IdcodeValue(IdcodeValue),
     // Random netlist constants
     .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid(RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid),
-    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma(RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked(RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev(RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev),
     .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction(RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma(RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma),
     .SiliconCreatorId(LcCtrlSiliconCreatorId[lc_ctrl_reg_pkg::SiliconCreatorIdWidth-1:0]),
     .ProductId(LcCtrlProductId[lc_ctrl_reg_pkg::ProductIdWidth-1:0]),
     .RevisionId(LcCtrlRevisionId[lc_ctrl_reg_pkg::RevisionIdWidth-1:0]),
@@ -226,8 +232,10 @@ module tb;
     parameters_cfg.alert_async_on = AlertAsyncOn;
     parameters_cfg.id_code_value = IdcodeValue;
     parameters_cfg.keymgr_div_invalid = RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid;
-    parameters_cfg.keymgr_div_test_dev_rma = RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma;
+    parameters_cfg.keymgr_div_test_unlocked = RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked;
+    parameters_cfg.keymgr_div_dev = RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev;
     parameters_cfg.keymgr_div_production = RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction;
+    parameters_cfg.keymgr_div_rma = RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma;
     uvm_config_db#(lc_ctrl_parameters_cfg)::set(null, "*", "parameters_cfg", parameters_cfg);
 
     // verilog_format: on

hw/ip/lc_ctrl/rtl/lc_ctrl.sv

@@ -21,11 +21,13 @@ module lc_ctrl
   // Idcode value for the JTAG.
   parameter logic [31:0] IdcodeValue = 32'h00000001,
   // Random netlist constants
-  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid    = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(0),
-  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(1),
-  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(2),
-  parameter lc_token_mux_t  RndCnstInvalidTokens         = {TokenMuxBits{1'b1}},
-  parameter bit             SecVolatileRawUnlockEn       = 0
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid      = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(0),
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(1),
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev          = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(2),
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction   = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(3),
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma          = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(4),
+  parameter lc_token_mux_t  RndCnstInvalidTokens           = {TokenMuxBits{1'b1}},
+  parameter bit             SecVolatileRawUnlockEn         = 0
 ) (
   // Life cycle controller clock
   input                                              clk_i,
@@ -700,11 +702,13 @@ module lc_ctrl
   ////////////
 
   lc_ctrl_fsm #(
-    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid     ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid     ),
-    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma  ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma  ),
-    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction  ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction  ),
-    .RndCnstInvalidTokens          ( RndCnstInvalidTokens          ),
-    .SecVolatileRawUnlockEn        ( SecVolatileRawUnlockEn        )
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid     ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid      ),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked ),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev         ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev          ),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction  ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction   ),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma         ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma          ),
+    .RndCnstInvalidTokens          ( RndCnstInvalidTokens           ),
+    .SecVolatileRawUnlockEn        ( SecVolatileRawUnlockEn         )
   ) u_lc_ctrl_fsm (
     .clk_i,
     .rst_ni,

hw/ip/lc_ctrl/rtl/lc_ctrl_fsm.sv

@@ -11,11 +11,13 @@ module lc_ctrl_fsm
   import lc_ctrl_reg_pkg::*;
   import lc_ctrl_state_pkg::*;
 #(// Random netlist constants
-  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid    = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(0),
-  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(1),
-  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(2),
-  parameter lc_token_mux_t  RndCnstInvalidTokens         = {TokenMuxBits{1'b1}},
-  parameter bit             SecVolatileRawUnlockEn       = 0
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid      = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(0),
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(1),
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev          = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(2),
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction   = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(3),
+  parameter lc_keymgr_div_t RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma          = LcKeymgrDivWidth'(4),
+  parameter lc_token_mux_t  RndCnstInvalidTokens           = {TokenMuxBits{1'b1}},
+  parameter bit             SecVolatileRawUnlockEn         = 0
 ) (
   // This module is combinational, but we
   // need the clock and reset for the assertions.
@@ -784,9 +786,11 @@ module lc_ctrl_fsm
 
   // LC signal decoder and broadcasting logic.
   lc_ctrl_signal_decode #(
-    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid    ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid    ),
-    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestDevRma ),
-    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction )
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid     ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivInvalid      ),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivTestUnlocked ),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev         ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivDev          ),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction  ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivProduction   ),
+    .RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma         ( RndCnstLcKeymgrDivRma          )
   ) u_lc_ctrl_signal_decode (
     .clk_i,
     .rst_ni,