diff --git a/evaluations/tokenomics-survey-2022_3_takahser.md b/evaluations/tokenomics-survey-2022_3_takahser.md index e6a3d2a20..53b26a0b9 100644 --- a/evaluations/tokenomics-survey-2022_3_takahser.md +++ b/evaluations/tokenomics-survey-2022_3_takahser.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Evaluation -- **Status:** In Progress +- **Status:** Accepted - **Application Document:** https://github.com/w3f/Grants-Program/blob/master/applications/tokenomics-survey-2022.md - **Milestone:** 3 - **Kusama Identity:** Address @@ -11,15 +11,15 @@ | **0a.** | Copyright and Licenses | | [Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/LICENSE) | - | | **0b.** | Documentation/Tutorial | | [Build Instructions](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/tree/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e#build-pdf) | - | | **0c.** | Methodology | | [*Methodology* Section](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/main.tex#L855) | - | -| **0d.** | Infrastructure | | [Build Instructions](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/README.md#build-pdf) | The "Docker files for software execution" are missing, but I think they're not relevant for this delivery. I suggest to amend the proposal to remove this part. | +| **0d.** | Infrastructure | | [Build Instructions](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/README.md#build-pdf) | The "Docker files for software execution" are missing, but I think they're not relevant for this delivery. | | **0e.** | Article | | [Draft Article](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/milestones/milestone_3.pdf) | - | -| **0e.1** | Article | | [Draft Article](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/milestones/milestone_3.pdf) | Not published yet. | +| **0e.1** | Article | | [Draft Article](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/milestones/milestone_3.pdf) | Submitted for publication at . | | **0e.2** | - Section: Published models | | [*Annotated Bibliography* Chapter](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/annotated_bibliography.bib) | - | | **0e.3** | - Section: Polkadot Parachain Economies | | [*Native Token Functions* Chapter](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/main.tex#L783) | - | | **0e.4** | - Appendix: Methodology | | [*Methodology* Chapter](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/main.tex#L856) | Personally, I found the pseudocode at step 2 in the flowchart in Figure 1 somehow difficult to understand. | | **0e.5** | - Section: Summary | | [*Summary* Chapter](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/main.tex#L837) | - | | 1 | Feedback | | [Github (55f19fe)](https://github.com/taqtiqa-mark/tokenomics-survey-2022/blob/55f19fe4fd1c9816b360b7419ce85d621b7ac12e/main.tex) | - | -| 2 | Publish | | **Penultimate step after all reviewer changes are complete.** [SSRN (e.g. FEN - Cryptocurrency Research eJournal)](https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/JELJOUR_Results.cfm?form_name=journalBrowse&journal_id=3839004), [IDEAS](https://ideas.repec.org/), [Arxiv (q-fin.GN)](https://arxiv.org/list/q-fin.GN/recent) | The working paper will be posted to [SSRN (e.g. FEN - Cryptocurrency Research eJournal)](https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/JELJOUR_Results.cfm?form_name=journalBrowse&journal_id=3839004), [IDEAS](https://ideas.repec.org/), [Arxiv (q-fin.GN)](https://arxiv.org/list/q-fin.GN/recent) | +| 2 | Publish | | [ResearchGate Pre-Print](http://dx.doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.33768.85763), [Screenshots of submissions for SSRN and IDEAS](https://github.com/w3f/Grant-Milestone-Delivery/pull/925#issuecomment-1705742763) | A preprint has been submitted to [ResearchGate](http://dx.doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.33768.85763), [SSRN and IDEAS](https://github.com/w3f/Grant-Milestone-Delivery/pull/925#issuecomment-1705742763). | Ideally all links inside the above table should include the commit hash, @@ -32,7 +32,5 @@ which was used for testing the delivery. It should also be checked if the softwa - Instead of the detailed summary of parachain token attributes a series of flowcharts/decision trees has been provided that aim to identify the scope of any token design w.r.t. the following attributes: Economy/Model/Equilibrium/Sector/Production/Monetary Type. - In the initial delivery there were a [few things](https://github.com/w3f/Grant-Milestone-Delivery/pull/925#pullrequestreview-1550254076) unclear in the paper but they were [addressed and fixed](https://github.com/w3f/Grant-Milestone-Delivery/pull/925#issuecomment-1655020762) very quickly by the grantee. - The only open points are: - - [ ] publish the paper - - [ ] amend the contract to remove Docker from the requirements (or implement it) - -### Pre-Notes + - [x] ~~publish the paper~~ + - [x] ~~amend the contract to remove Docker from the requirements (or implement it)~~