ESP32 POE Version

[Imanol82]

Hello!

I'm trying to make this proyecto on an ESP32 C3 POE with RS485 isolated board:

I would like to use 1 Master and 1 Slave, I know in this way I could't write but is OK, in this project I only need to read.

So, I have added neccesary external components to the yaml to use this ESP32 but something is wrong:

I have delete this code because the new post is more clear.

https://github.com/txubelaxu/esphome-jk-bms/discussions/26#discussioncomment-11296283

Thank you very much for your help!!

[Imanol82]

In the end I've installed Sleeper85 project and works perfectly in this POE esp32.

Thank you very much!

[Imanol82]

Hello, I'm back.

I've been using Sleeper85 (and yours) YamBMS for a few weeks and it works well with the ESP32 POE (many thanks to @Sleeper85 for all your help), but I still like the idea of ​​using the ESP32 only for reading the system, not like the Master. That is, let my both JK-PB (master + slave) connect via CAN to my Deye inverter.

I think it is the most correct way of working.

So I'm trying again to install your project to the ESP32 ETH01-evo POE.

The scheme is very similar to the one I used with the YamBMS, because the RS485 side is yours. So I thought it would be very easy to port it.

After changing the pins, adding the repository where the Ethernet component is and adding it, I left the code like this:

substitutions:
  esp_name: esp-rs485-gw
  bms0_name: bms1
  bms1_name: bms2
  device_description: "Monitor two JK-BMS via RS485 internal"
  external_components_source: github://txubelaxu/esphome-jk-bms@main #github://syssi/esphome-jk-bms@main
  tx_pin_uart_0: GPIO2 #GPIO1 #GPIO16
  rx_pin_uart_0: GPIO5 #GPIO3 #GPIO17
  talk_pin_rs485: GPIO4

esphome:
  name: ${esp_name}
  comment: ${device_description}
  project:
    name: "txubelaxu.esphome-jk-bms"
    version: 2.0.1
#  libraries:
#    - "ArduinoJson"
#  includes:
    #- ./components/ArduinoJson/ArduinoJson.h
    #- ./components/ArduinoJson/ArduinoJson.hpp
    #- ./components/ArduinoJson/Configuration.hpp
#    - ./components/json/json_util.h

#esp32:
#  board: esp32dev #nodemcu-32s #wemos_d1_mini32
#  framework:
#    type: esp-idf

#esp8266:
#  board: d1_mini

esp32:
  board: esp32-c3-devkitm-1
  variant: esp32c3
  framework:
    type: esp-idf
    version: latest
    platform_version: 6.5.0

external_components:
# - source: ${external_components_source}
#   refresh: 0s
  #- source:
  #    type: git
  #    url: https://github.com/esphome/esphome
  #    ref: dev
  #  components: [ json ]

  - source: ./components
    refresh: 0s
    components: [ jk_rs485_sniffer , jk_rs485_bms ]
  - source: 
      type: git
      url: https://github.com/esphome/esphome
      ref: d5bdf2575c151abfad39b6c24c3856395a7d0901
    components:
      - ethernet

ethernet:
  id: my_network
  type: DM9051 # W5500
  clk_pin: 7
  mosi_pin: 10
  miso_pin: 3
  cs_pin: 9
  interrupt_pin: 8
  reset_pin: 6
  clock_speed: 20MHz
  manual_ip:
    static_ip: 192.168.178.114 
    gateway: 192.168.178.1
    subnet: 255.255.255.0
    dns1: 192.168.178.1

ota:
  - platform: esphome
 
...

But it keeps giving me the same error... And I don't know how to continue.

@txubelaxu , could you help me to continue? I have always thought that this ESP32 POE is very interesting for this kind of proyects. It is wonderful to have to connect it only with a POE network cable, no wifi, no psu...

You can use me as a tester :)

Thank you very much for your work. It's a pleasure to find such interesting projects.

Mila esker, benetan zure laguntza asko eskertuko nukeela.

[txubelaxu]

Solved @Imanol82!!

I have just changed the code to avoid that error.

Ia zelan doakizun modu honetan!! Esango dostezu!!

[Imanol82]

Thank you very much! @txubelaxu
What files do I have to update to test? I'll try it when I get home.

Asmatu det, bizkaitarra zea ezta? jaja. Eskerrikasko zure lanagatik.

[txubelaxu]

Well, I have updated my github. Only one file changed: jk_rs485_sniffer.cpp

[Imanol82]

Thank you very much!!!!

[txubelaxu]

Congratulations!!

Ez horregaitik!!!

[Imanol82]

It's amazing my friend. Here some pictures.
I'll make a 3D box and that's all.

Txubelaxu POE Version: haha

Thank you very much!!

[Imanol82]

Well, hello again.

Updated version. Fits better and gnd is isolated.

Thanks again @txubelaxu

[txubelaxu]

Atzera bota behar izan dot aldaketa, yambms-ak arazoak emon dauelako. Komentatu dezakezu lerro hori eta kitto, zuzentzen dodan bitartean.

[Imanol82]

Joer, ba nik konpilatu det eta dena primeran. Arazoak badituzu esango didazu ze komentatu behar dudan. Oso interesgarria da plaka hau.
Oraintxe jarriko ditut argazkiak ikusteko.
Nolabait lortu beharko zenuke ondo ibiltzea, kriston ondo geatzen da horrela jeje

Pentxatzen hari naizena da rs485-ttl a aldatzea, beste modeluagatik, gnd isolatua daukana baina Talk pina eztuena. Eztakit merezi duen ala ez...

Benetan mila esker!!!!

[txubelaxu]

Itxura oso ona sortu dozun tramankulua!!
Igual aldaketa igo neban zuk konpilatu eta gero.
Nik ipini dotset talk pina ez duen modulo hori eta primeran doa.

[Imanol82]

Ba TTL plaka aldatuko dut (etxean badakat bateon bat) eta itxura hobetuko da, plaka motzagoa da eta.
3D kaixa bat egin eta listo. Igoko det STL-a bukatzean :)

Lehenengo yaml-an talk pina komentatu eta nahikoa da ezta?

Sleeperrena ere ondo geratu zen bere kaxan. Baina nahiago det zurea, eztet BMS-DEYE artean ezer sartu nahi...

(arraroa egiten zait github-en euskaraz ibiltzea jeje)

[Imanol82]

Orain bai jeje, kaixa egin eta amaituta

[txubelaxu]

Zelako itxurea!!!

Bai, pina komentatu eta kitto! Plaka horregaz ez bait da beharrezkoa talk-pin-ik erabiltzea eta ez da derrigorrezkoa bez egotea bat kodigoan.

[txubelaxu]

@Imanol82, zuk dituzula 2 bateri, honelako portaera dute zure BMSek?:

[Imanol82]

Bai, bat beti atzetik doa... Hobetzeko 2 bateriaen erresistentzia ahalik eta berdinen izan behar du. Eta BMSaren V-a eta I-a ahalik eta ondoen kalibratu behar dira. Baina neri berdina gertatzen zait, bat bestearen atzetik doa beti...

Gainera ezdakit zergatik, bigarrena asko deskonektatzen da...

Bien arteko rj45 kablea aldatuko det ea konpontzen den...

Sleeperrekin ez zen gertatzen, eta RS485 aldea zurea da...
Desberdintasun bakarra zan harekin 2 BMSak Slave moduan zeudela, orain bat Master eta bestea Slave moduan daude (nahiago det modu honetan, Deyearekin komunikazioa hobeto doa)

[Imanol82]

Hello @txubelaxu.
I saw something on your GitHub that I hadn't seen before...

JK-PBx, hw 15.XA, sw 15.11, using JK02_32S (reported by [@denveronly])

What does this change affect? I have PB 15.

Thank you very much!!

[txubelaxu]

where is that comment exactly?

[Imanol82]

Here:

This is not OK?

[Imanol82]

I see that only is an information, is not neccesary to change nothing...

haha. I read too early this morning...

[Imanol82]

The thing is that I am looking everything because something is not going well... I have seen that the Deye only sees the SOC of the Master BMS.

And I don't know if it is the fault of the BMSs or if it is because the ESP32 is connected.

I explain to you.

I have updated the firmware of the 2 BMS to version 15.33.

They are limited to 140A charge/discharge.

I boot the system, the Deye sees the average SOC and 266A. Perfect. But in 2-3 seconds, it only sees the SOC of the Master BMS and 133A charge/discharge, it seems that it only sees the Master BMS.

I have changed the cable that connects the 2 BMSs, and nothing.

Tonight I'll try removing the ESP32, see what happens...

[txubelaxu]

But are you using CAN cable between ESP and Inverter? You are using RS485 only, aren't you?

[Imanol82]

Yes, I'm using only RS485. But I don't know what else can I try.

[txubelaxu]

You can try a "Force Firmware" (downgrade). Maybe there are more people with same problem. El El mié, 4 dic 2024 a las 14:38, Imanol82 ***@***.***> escribió:

…

Yes, I'm using only RS485. But I don't know what else can I try — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#26 (reply in thread)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/BFHIJMCMROAJRCONZFTI3IL2D4AWVAVCNFSM6AAAAABNYJYLAKVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43URDJONRXK43TNFXW4Q3PNVWWK3TUHMYTCNBWGE2TSMA> . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.*** com>

[Imanol82]

I'll try tonight

[txubelaxu]

Sorry for the question, Imanol, but, where has that firmware published?

lol

[Imanol82]

It was shared by a colleague on the Solar DIY telegram.

In theory it fixed the SOC calculation problems.
I haven't been able to downgrade... let's see if I can find time tomorrow.

Thanks!!

[Imanol82]

Well @txubelaxu , first of all, I have changed the title of this post, i think more people will find it in this way.

Second. I have downgraded to the 15.30 as you suggested, and nothing has changed, the same error.
The Deye only sees the Master BMS, I check it easily by looking at the SOC and the charge/discharge currents.

Then I tried disconnecting the ESP32, and bam! It reads the SOC and charge/discharge current well, both BMSs.
I have reconnected the esp32 and again, it only reads the Master BMS.

It seems to me that there is some conflict due to having 2 BMSs in parallel, one Master and the other Slave, and adding the ESP32 reader.

Any ideas?

Thank you very much my friend.

Eskerrikasko!!!

[Imanol82]

Before making the box I was thinking about how to leave out the 6 pins for when programming from the USB and this solution occurred to me.
I have made a new assembly, so as not to use the previous one that is very reused and this is the result:

Now to take measurements and make a box...

Thank you @txubelaxu for your work :)

Eskerrikasko!!!

[Sleeper85]

@Imanol82

How are you going to solve the JK-BMS faulty SoC issues?
Are you counting on a JK firmware upgrade?
Just yesterday a YamBMS user found himself at 0% while his two JK-PB BMS were showing 59 and 54% with 3.0V cells.

[Imanol82]

No no, I haven't been able to solve anything... I don't know about these things. I just hope you guys are able to fix it.
Lucky it doesn't bother me much because when they are in parallel the two banks work more or less at the same time...
The only thing I've seen is that when disconnecting the esp32 the deye communicates well with the JK, when connecting it, it only sees the master again.

[Imanol82]

Hello @Sleeper85 .
I just realized why you asked me about the SOC falls. It's because of what I put in your project (I didn't remember).

This error:

The truth is that @txubelaxu helped me adapt his project and I change your ESP32 for his ESP32. I have always preferred to be a simple data reader, I don't like to be in the middle of CAN communication.

Sorry I can't help you. Thank you very much

[Imanol82]

Hello @txubelaxu. While the issue of communication between the Slave and the Deye is being resolved, I have drawn a 3D box for this project.

Tomorrow I'll print it and if everything fits well, I'll upload the STL.

Thank you!

[Imanol82]

Hello.

I have updated the BMS to version 15.35 and it seems to have solved the SOC issue.
The Deye shows the average of two SOCs and the maximum charge/discharge current is maintained at 266A even if the ESP32 is connected.

So it seems like now everything is perfect again :)

Thank you very much @txubelaxu

[Imanol82]

Since I updated to 15.35, the BMS2 has not disconnected again. Let's see if everything works well :)

Thanks!

[Imanol82]

Well, it really seems that firmware 15.35 has solved everything. Does it make any sense @txubelaxu?

Thank you very much.

@Sleeper85 , test you problems with firmware 15.35

Eskerrikasko eta eguberri on!!!!

[Sleeper85]

@Imanol82 I don't have a JK-PB ah ah.

@txubelaxu What impact can this new firmware have on your code?

[Imanol82]

Ok but as you asked last week info because one user has my same problem... Ask him to update to 15.35. For testing :)

[Imanol82]

I have spoken with more Telegram users and to they didn't happen the same thing as me (their esp projects works fine with 15.30). I don't know if it will affect the ESP that is used or not...

[Sleeper85]

Ok but as you asked last week info because one user has my same problem... Ask him to update to 15.35. For testing :)

The user who had problems was with 15.33 he upgraded to 15.35, wait and see.