diff --git a/worlds/hk/Options.py b/worlds/hk/Options.py
index ef7fbd0dfef6..4538e4279204 100644
--- a/worlds/hk/Options.py
+++ b/worlds/hk/Options.py
@@ -406,6 +406,10 @@ class ExtraPlatforms(DefaultOnToggle):
     """Places additional platforms to make traveling throughout Hallownest more convenient."""
 
 
+class SharedItems(Toggle):
+    """Places all Vanilla items as AP Items so they can be shared within one slot. This will inflate hint prices."""
+
+
 class DeathLinkShade(Choice):
     """Sets whether to create a shade when you are killed by a DeathLink and how to handle your existing shade, if any.
 
@@ -488,7 +492,7 @@ class CostSanityHybridChance(Range):
     **{
         option.__name__: option
         for option in (
-            StartLocation, Goal, WhitePalace, ExtraPlatforms, StartingGeo,
+            StartLocation, Goal, WhitePalace, ExtraPlatforms, SharedItems, StartingGeo,
             DeathLink, DeathLinkShade, DeathLinkBreaksFragileCharms,
             MinimumGeoPrice, MaximumGeoPrice,
             MinimumGrubPrice, MaximumGrubPrice,
diff --git a/worlds/hk/__init__.py b/worlds/hk/__init__.py
index 48e0f266726d..af9f8d101b82 100644
--- a/worlds/hk/__init__.py
+++ b/worlds/hk/__init__.py
@@ -252,7 +252,7 @@ def _add(item_name: str, location_name: str, randomized: bool):
             if item_name in junk_replace:
                 item_name = self.get_filler_item_name()
 
-            item = self.create_item(item_name) if not vanilla or location_name == "Start" else self.create_event(item_name)
+            item = self.create_item(item_name) if not vanilla or location_name == "Start" or self.multiworld.SharedItems[self.player] else self.create_event(item_name)
 
             if location_name == "Start":
                 if item_name in randomized_starting_items:
@@ -277,7 +277,7 @@ def _add(item_name: str, location_name: str, randomized: bool):
 
         for option_key, option in hollow_knight_randomize_options.items():
             randomized = getattr(self.multiworld, option_key)[self.player]
-            if randomized or option_key not in logicless_options:
+            if randomized or option_key not in logicless_options or self.multiworld.SharedItems[self.player]:
                 for item_name, location_name in zip(option.items, option.locations):
                     if item_name in junk_replace:
                         item_name = self.get_filler_item_name()
@@ -502,7 +502,7 @@ def create_location(self, name: str, vanilla=False) -> HKLocation:
 
         region = self.multiworld.get_region("Menu", self.player)
 
-        if vanilla:
+        if vanilla and not self.multiworld.SharedItems[self.player]:
             loc = HKLocation(self.player, name,
                              None, region, costs=costs, vanilla=vanilla,
                              basename=basename)