Failing to receive signature from Gnosis Safe multisig app

[eugenPtr]

Describe the bug

I am building an app that needs to be able to receive messages signed with Gnosis Safe
While this worked well with Metamask, I am getting a Request expired. Please try again. error when I do it through Gnosis Safe. I have tested this on Sepolia, signing the message right away and having the tx confirmed by Safe in under 1 minute. The app keeps waiting to receive the signature from WC until the request times out.

To fetch the signature I am using signMessageAsync from wagmi's useSignMessage hook.

SDK Version (if relevant)

• @web3modal/wagmi - 4.1.6
• wagmi - 2.5.19

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Login through WC with Safe Wallet on Desktop
2. User clicks a button requesting them to Sign a message
3. User is redirected to the Safe wallet page in the browser
4. User signs tx which gets confirmed less than a minute after
5. User then goes to the app when a loader is spinning until the signature is received
6. After a few minutes the browser console logs the error: Request expired. Please try again

Expected behavior
The signature is received after a while, before timing out

[linear[bot]]

CR-12 Failing to receive signature from Gnosis Safe multisig app

[ganchoradkov]

hey @eugenPtr session requests have default expiry of 5 minutes. Is it taking longer for you to sign?

[eugenPtr]

hey @ganchoradkov, thanks for picking this up. It's taking under a minute to sign and see the transaction confirmed.

[eugenPtr]

@ganchoradkov any idea what the issue could be here?

[glitch-txs]

Please update Wagmi and Web3Modal packages to latest. Feel free to repoen if the issue persists.

[ryanberckmans]

I'm experiencing this same issue where useSignMessage, WalletConnect, and Gnosis Safe doesn't detect the Safe contract's emitted SignMsg event and hangs in pending until timing out.

I'm using wagmi latest (2.10.9), @walletconnect/ethereum-provider latest (2.13.3), and @walletconnect/modal latest (2.6.2).

[Starfeathers71]

Not one of the wallets and connectors work

[ryanberckmans]

I'm experiencing this same issue where useSignMessage, WalletConnect, and Gnosis Safe doesn't detect the Safe contract's emitted SignMsg event and hangs in pending until timing out.

I'm using wagmi latest (2.10.9), @walletconnect/ethereum-provider latest (2.13.3), and @walletconnect/modal latest (2.6.2).

I ended up "solving" this by writing a wrapper library that polls for the creation of the eip-1271 hash via useReadContract in parallel with the useSignMessage. Then I abort the pending useSignMessage when the eip-1271 hash becomes available.

[eugenPtr]

@ryanberckmans do you mind sharing the workaround?

[glitch-txs]

I'm not able to repro in the latest: https://lab.web3modal.com/library/wagmi/

I'm able to sign a message with Safe succefully.

[Dhuliang]

I'm not able to repro in the latest: https://lab.web3modal.com/library/wagmi/我无法在最新版本中重现： https://lab.web3modal.com/library/wagmi/

I'm able to sign a message with Safe succefully.我能够成功使用 Safe 签署消息。

Have you signed the message and verified the message? Signing message is ok, but recover from address is not connected to wallet address

[glitch-txs]

please provider a MRE

[gregdhill]

Currently also facing this issue with @wagmi/[email protected] and [email protected]