You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
As it stands today, when moderators use the "Delete This Game" feature, this action can't be undone. Even when you opt to merge one game into another, we can't undo it.
The deleter/merger deletes/merges these features:
Played games, wishlists, unwishlists
Recommended list items
Reviews and review comments
Cross recommendations
Poll votes and comments
Competition entries
Game news
But the deleter just deletes these things; the merger simply updates all of those rows to change them to point to the new game, with no record that they used to point at an old game.
Furthermore, the merger doesn't merge any simple text fields:
Title
Author
Genre
Description
Version
License
Dev system
Language
Series info
And, of course, the cover art isn't merged, either. (I separately filed #395 that we should merge cover art when the target game doesn't even have cover art.)
All of this data on the deleted game is simply deleted forever, along with its edit history.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
I think this would be an enormously challenging project; I don't expect that anybody will work on this any time soon. But I would be willing to review a PR (or, perhaps, a series of PRs?) to implement this.
When deleting, I think we'd want/need to move the deleted game and its history to an archive table. (I think it would not be wise to just mark the game as "deleted" and then try to update all of the other code in the entire site to avoid showing deleted games; it would be a neverending source of bugs.)
When merging, we'd need to keep a record of all the metadata that we merged, so we could click a button to put it all back where it came from.
dfabulich
changed the title
"Delete This Game" merge tool should have an "Undo" mechanism
"Delete This Game" should have an "Undo" mechanism
Sep 2, 2024
dfabulich
transferred this issue from iftechfoundation/ifdb-suggestion-tracker
Oct 8, 2024
As it stands today, when moderators use the "Delete This Game" feature, this action can't be undone. Even when you opt to merge one game into another, we can't undo it.
The deleter/merger deletes/merges these features:
But the deleter just deletes these things; the merger simply updates all of those rows to change them to point to the new game, with no record that they used to point at an old game.
Furthermore, the merger doesn't merge any simple text fields:
And, of course, the cover art isn't merged, either. (I separately filed #395 that we should merge cover art when the target game doesn't even have cover art.)
All of this data on the deleted game is simply deleted forever, along with its edit history.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: