diff --git a/.changelogs/fix_llms-posts-select2-improvements.yml b/.changelogs/fix_llms-posts-select2-improvements.yml
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..5b763f4551
--- /dev/null
+++ b/.changelogs/fix_llms-posts-select2-improvements.yml
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+significance: patch
+type: dev
+links:
+  - "#2805"
+entry: Improved llmsPostsSelect2 method when called on multiple elements at
+  once, each with different options.
diff --git a/assets/js/llms-admin.js b/assets/js/llms-admin.js
index 43d7edd4c1..596d86bbf4 100644
--- a/assets/js/llms-admin.js
+++ b/assets/js/llms-admin.js
@@ -51,96 +51,98 @@
 	 * @return void
 	 */
 	$.fn.llmsPostsSelect2 = function( options ) {
+		var localOptions = options;
+
+		this.each( function() {
+			var self = $( this ),
+				options = localOptions || {},
+				defaults = {
+					multiple: false,
+					placeholder: self.attr( 'data-placeholder' ) || ( undefined !== LLMS.l10n ? LLMS.l10n.translate( 'Select a Course/Membership' ) : 'Select a Course/Membership' ),
+					post_type: self.attr( 'data-post-type' ) || 'post',
+					post_statuses: self.attr( 'data-post-statuses' ) || 'publish',
+					instructor_id: null,
+					allow_clear: self.attr( 'data-post-type' ) || false,
+					width: null,
+				};
+
+			$.each( defaults, function( setting ) {
+				if ( self.attr( 'data-' + setting ) ) {
+					options[ setting ] = self.attr( 'data-' + setting );
+				}
+			} );
 
-		var self = this,
-			options = options || {},
-			defaults = {
-				multiple: false,
-				placeholder: undefined !== LLMS.l10n ? LLMS.l10n.translate( 'Select a Course/Membership' ) : 'Select a Course/Membership',
-				post_type: self.attr( 'data-post-type' ) || 'post',
-				post_statuses: self.attr( 'data-post-statuses' ) || 'publish',
-				instructor_id: null,
-				allow_clear: self.attr( 'data-post-type' ) || false,
-				width: null,
-			};
-
-		$.each( defaults, function( setting ) {
-			if ( self.attr( 'data-' + setting ) ) {
-				options[ setting ] = self.attr( 'data-' + setting );
+			if ( 'multiple' === self.attr( 'multiple' ) ) {
+				options.multiple = true;
 			}
-		} );
 
-		if ( 'multiple' === self.attr( 'multiple' ) ) {
-			options.multiple = true;
-		}
+			options = $.extend( defaults, options );
 
-		options = $.extend( defaults, options );
-
-		this.llmsSelect2( {
-			allowClear: options.allow_clear,
-			ajax: {
-				dataType: 'JSON',
-				delay: 250,
-				method: 'POST',
-				url: window.ajaxurl,
-				data: function( params ) {
-					return {
-						action: 'select2_query_posts',
-						page: ( params.page ) ? params.page - 1 : 0, // 0 index the pages to make it simpler for the database query
-						post_type: options.post_type,
-						instructor_id : options.instructor_id,
-						post_statuses: options.post_statuses,
-						term: params.term,
-						_ajax_nonce: window.llms.ajax_nonce,
-					};
-				},
-				processResults: function( data, params ) {
+			$( this ).llmsSelect2( {
+				allowClear: options.allow_clear,
+				ajax: {
+					dataType: 'JSON',
+					delay: 250,
+					method: 'POST',
+					url: window.ajaxurl,
+					data: function( params ) {
+						return {
+							action: 'select2_query_posts',
+							page: ( params.page ) ? params.page - 1 : 0, // 0 index the pages to make it simpler for the database query
+							post_type: options.post_type,
+							instructor_id : options.instructor_id,
+							post_statuses: options.post_statuses,
+							term: params.term,
+							_ajax_nonce: window.llms.ajax_nonce,
+						};
+					},
+					processResults: function( data, params ) {
+
+						// recursive function for creating
+						function map_data( items ) {
+
+							// this is a flat array of results
+							// used when only one post type is selected
+							// and to format children when using optgroups with multiple post types
+							if ( Array.isArray( items ) ) {
+								return $.map( items, function( item ) {
+									return format_item( item );
+								} );
+
+								// this sets up the top level optgroups when using multiple post types
+							} else {
+								return $.map( items, function( item ) {
+									return {
+										text: item.label,
+										children: map_data( item.items ),
+									}
+								} );
+							}
+						}
 
-					// recursive function for creating
-					function map_data( items ) {
-
-						// this is a flat array of results
-						// used when only one post type is selected
-						// and to format children when using optgroups with multiple post types
-						if ( Array.isArray( items ) ) {
-							return $.map( items, function( item ) {
-								return format_item( item );
-							} );
-
-							// this sets up the top level optgroups when using multiple post types
-						} else {
-							return $.map( items, function( item ) {
-								return {
-									text: item.label,
-									children: map_data( item.items ),
-								}
-							} );
+						// format a single result (option)
+						function format_item( item ) {
+							return {
+								text: item.name,
+								id: item.id,
+							};
 						}
-					}
 
-					// format a single result (option)
-					function format_item( item ) {
 						return {
-							text: item.name,
-							id: item.id,
+							results: map_data( data.items ),
+							pagination: {
+								more: data.more
+							}
 						};
-					}
-
-					return {
-						results: map_data( data.items ),
-						pagination: {
-							more: data.more
-						}
-					};
 
+					},
 				},
-			},
-			cache: true,
-			placeholder: options.placeholder,
-			multiple: options.multiple,
-			width: options.width,
+				cache: true,
+				placeholder: options.placeholder,
+				multiple: options.multiple,
+				width: options.width,
+			} );
 		} );
-
 	};
 
 	// automatically setup any select with the `llms-posts-select2` class