You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
The //mesh/@optimization attribute is being added in #1382 with recognition for 3 values of the attribute:
"" (empty string): no mesh optimization is done
convex_hull: use the convex hull of the specified mesh
convex_decomposition: decompose the mesh into convex sub-meshes (using parameters from //mesh/convex_decomposition)
It could also be useful for a user to specify assert_convex when they believe a mesh is convex and that an error should be raised if it is found to not be convex. Verifying this would require code from gz-common (or similar) to get the mesh data for analysis, so it couldn't be added directly to sdformat, but it could be useful for some users.
There is a use case for wanting to specify both assert_convex and convex_hull (a user may want to use the convex_hull optimization with a mesh known to be convex since it may consolidate triangle faces into larger polygon faces), so I would suggest a new attribute //mesh/@assert_convex.
Alternatives considered
Instead of a new attribute, the assert_convex behavior could be specified in //mesh/@optimization.
Also, I've mentioned this as a potential use case, but I'm not sure how much user demand there actually is. The convex_hull option may be adequate, combined with a CLI tool in another repository for evaluating how close to convex a given mesh is.
Implementation suggestion
Additional context
Thanks to @SeanCurtis-TRI for suggesting the assert_convex name and discussing this potential use case.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Desired behavior
The
//mesh/@optimization
attribute is being added in #1382 with recognition for 3 values of the attribute:""
(empty string): no mesh optimization is doneconvex_hull
: use the convex hull of the specified meshconvex_decomposition
: decompose the mesh into convex sub-meshes (using parameters from//mesh/convex_decomposition
)It could also be useful for a user to specify
assert_convex
when they believe a mesh is convex and that an error should be raised if it is found to not be convex. Verifying this would require code from gz-common (or similar) to get the mesh data for analysis, so it couldn't be added directly tosdformat
, but it could be useful for some users.There is a use case for wanting to specify both
assert_convex
andconvex_hull
(a user may want to use theconvex_hull
optimization with a mesh known to be convex since it may consolidate triangle faces into larger polygon faces), so I would suggest a new attribute//mesh/@assert_convex
.Alternatives considered
Instead of a new attribute, the
assert_convex
behavior could be specified in//mesh/@optimization
.Also, I've mentioned this as a potential use case, but I'm not sure how much user demand there actually is. The
convex_hull
option may be adequate, combined with a CLI tool in another repository for evaluating how close to convex a given mesh is.Implementation suggestion
Additional context
Thanks to @SeanCurtis-TRI for suggesting the
assert_convex
name and discussing this potential use case.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: