The subscriptionCallback overrides _subscriptionCallback making Dahsboard ineffective

[nonix]

Hi
I am not a 100% sure, but I think only one subscriptionCallback can be registered. Once I register subscriptionCallback in the sketch (Eample: Basic.ino), the Dashboard Services tool will become ineffective, since any mqtt message sent is trapped by sketch subscriptionCallback rather than WifiMQTTManager::_subscriptionCallback, which e.g. triggers restart

Thank you,
N.

[koffing]

Yes, only one subscriptionCallback can be registered and the one that runs (in my sketch) is the one inside the library file not from my sketch. Even after I disabled the subscriptionCallback inside the library, the callback in my sketch still not working. I'll tinker with the library more

[TinajaLabs]

I think I'm having a similar issue... confusion about which subscriptionCallback is being called; the one in basic, or the one in WiFiMQTTManager.

In my case the confusion happens after my wemos d1 mini loses connection to the mqtt server. You can see it sets up and calls the subscriptionCallback as defined in top level, basic.ino (I've renamed it, but for simplicity, I'll call this basic.ino).

As an aside, you can see I've added a new parameter called mqtt_topic_loc. I'll be pre-pending that string to the topic as the location attributes (city/building/room) info for all my devices.

Here's the startup from terminal window:

18:27:25.658 -> 
18:27:25.658 -> 
18:27:25.691 -> WMM: clientId: Tinaja_a020a6194f75
18:27:25.691 -> WMM: mounting FS...
18:27:25.758 -> WMM: mounted file system...
18:27:25.758 -> WMM: reading config file...
18:27:25.791 -> WMM: opened config file...
18:27:25.791 -> {"friendly_name":"Under bed night light","mqtt_topic_loc":"kensington/home/bedroom","mqtt_server":"tinaja-co","mqtt_port":"1883"}
18:27:25.791 -> WMM: parsed json...
18:27:25.791 -> WMM: lets try to connect to WiFi...
18:27:25.791 -> WMM: entering config mode...
18:27:25.791 -> WMM: 192.168.4.1
18:27:25.791 -> WMM: connect your device to WiFi SSID Tinaja_a020a6194f75 to configure WiFi and MQTT...
18:28:26.993 -> WMM: should save config...
18:28:28.025 -> WMM: connected to WiFi!!...
18:28:28.025 -> WMM: saving config...
18:28:28.025 -> {
18:28:28.025 ->   "friendly_name": "Under bed night light",
18:28:28.025 ->   "mqtt_topic_loc": "kensington/home/bedroom",
18:28:28.025 ->   "mqtt_server": "tinaja-co",
18:28:28.025 ->   "mqtt_port": "1883"
18:28:28.025 -> }WMM: 
18:28:28.025 -> WMM: local IP:192.168.1.113
18:28:28.025 -> WMM: _mqtt_server: tinaja-co
18:28:28.025 -> WMM: _mqtt_port: 1883
18:28:28.025 -> WMM: _mqtt_topic_loc: kensington/home/bedroom
18:28:28.025 -> WMM: clientId: Tinaja_a020a6194f75
18:28:28.025 -> WMM: attempting MQTT connection...mqtt connected...via setup...
# --------------------->>
18:28:30.390 -> subscribing to some topics:
18:28:30.390 ->   kensington/home/roomnight-light/wemosd1-1/Tinaja_a020a6194f75/output
18:28:30.390 -> WMM: subscribed to service...
# <<------------------------
18:28:30.390 -> Sending message to MQTT topic: deviceLog/Tinaja_a020a6194f75
18:28:30.426 -> {
18:28:30.426 ->   "deviceType": "ESP8266",
18:28:30.426 ->   "deviceId": "Tinaja_a020a6194f75",
18:28:30.426 ->   "name": "Under bed night light",
18:28:30.426 ->   "location": "kensington/home/bedroom",
18:28:30.426 ->   "chipId": "194f75",
18:28:30.426 ->   "sketchName": "tinaja-wemosd1mini-neopixel-nightlight-1.ino"
18:28:30.426 -> }
18:28:30.426 -> messageBuffer: {"deviceType":"ESP8266","deviceId":"Tinaja_a020a6194f75","name":"Under bed night light","location":"kensington/home/bedroom","chipId":"194f75","sketchName":"tinaja-wemosd1mini-neopixel-nightlight-1.ino"}
18:28:30.456 -> WMM: Success sending message to register the device...
18:28:32.255 ->  tinaja started and waiting...
18:30:50.338 -> WMM: subscriptionCallback called... top level
18:30:50.338 -> Message arrived on topic in top level: kensington/home/roomnight-light/wemosd1-1/Tinaja_a020a6194f75/output. Payload: 1
18:30:50.338 -> free heap: 41376
18:30:50.338 -> mqtt pub - LED State: 1
18:30:55.333 -> WMM: subscriptionCallback called... top level
18:30:55.333 -> Message arrived on topic in top level: kensington/home/roomnight-light/wemosd1-1/Tinaja_a020a6194f75/output. Payload: 0
18:30:55.333 -> free heap: 41376
18:30:55.333 -> mqtt pub - LED State: 0

In the above you can see it configured to access subscriptionCallback at the top level, ie., in basic.ino.

The following is where it fails to connect to mqtt and the retries begin.

05:16:12.228 -> free heap: 41688
05:16:12.228 -> mqtt pub - LED State: 1
05:16:17.197 -> WMM: subscriptionCallback called... top level
05:16:17.230 -> Message arrived on topic in top level: kensington/home/roomnight-light/wemosd1-1/Tinaja_a020a6194f75/output. Payload: 0
05:16:17.230 -> free heap: 42360
05:16:17.230 -> mqtt pub - LED State: 0
05:16:32.201 -> WMM: subscriptionCallback called... top level
05:16:32.201 -> Message arrived on topic in top level: kensington/home/roomnight-light/wemosd1-1/Tinaja_a020a6194f75/output. Payload: 1
05:16:32.235 -> free heap: 41688
05:16:32.235 -> mqtt pub - LED State: 1
05:16:38.498 -> WMM: attempting MQTT connection...mqtt connect failed, rc=-2 try again in 5 seconds...
05:16:48.962 -> WMM: attempting MQTT connection...mqtt connect failed, rc=-2 try again in 5 seconds...
05:17:02.996 -> WMM: attempting MQTT connection...mqtt connect failed, rc=-4 try again in 5 seconds...

Then when it gets connected again, it comes back on the _subscriptionCallback which is not the same as subscriptionCallback. As a result, the subscription is received but there is no code within _subscriptionCallback to turn the leds on or off.

05:35:30.164 -> WMM: attempting MQTT connection...mqtt connect failed, rc=-4 try again in 5 seconds...
05:35:50.562 -> WMM: attempting MQTT connection...mqtt connected...via reconnect loop...
05:35:53.494 -> subscribing to some topics:
05:35:53.494 ->   kensington/home/roomnight-light/wemosd1-1/Tinaja_a020a6194f75/output
05:35:53.527 -> WMM: subscribed to service...
05:36:15.562 -> WMM: attempting MQTT connection...mqtt connected...via reconnect loop...
# --------------------->>
05:36:17.062 -> subscribing to some topics:
05:36:17.062 ->   kensington/home/roomnight-light/wemosd1-1/Tinaja_a020a6194f75/output
05:36:17.062 -> WMM: subscribed to service...
05:36:37.262 -> WMM: _subscriptionCallback called...
# <<------------------------
05:36:37.295 -> WMM: Message arrived on topic in WifiMQTTManager: kensington/home/roomnight-light/wemosd1-1/Tinaja_a020a6194f75/output. Message: 0
05:36:52.264 -> WMM: _subscriptionCallback called...
05:36:52.298 -> WMM: Message arrived on topic in WifiMQTTManager: kensington/home/roomnight-light/wemosd1-1/Tinaja_a020a6194f75/output. Message: 1

Thanks for any tips,
Chris.