diff --git a/worlds/raft/__init__.py b/worlds/raft/__init__.py
index 1ecf3ede12e9..62816cb09f67 100644
--- a/worlds/raft/__init__.py
+++ b/worlds/raft/__init__.py
@@ -50,9 +50,16 @@ def create_items(self):
         maximumResourcePackAmount = max(minRPSpecified, maxRPSpecified)
         # Generate item pool
         pool = []
+        frequencyItems = []
         for item in item_table:
             raft_item = self.create_item_replaceAsNecessary(item["name"])
+            if "Frequency" in item["name"]:
+                frequencyItems.append(raft_item)
             pool.append(raft_item)
+        if self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player].value <= 3:
+            if not hasattr(self.multiworld, "raft_frequencyItemsPerPlayer"):
+                self.multiworld.raft_frequencyItemsPerPlayer = {}
+            self.multiworld.raft_frequencyItemsPerPlayer[self.player] = frequencyItems
 
         extraItemNamePool = []
         extras = len(location_table) - len(item_table) - 1 # Victory takes up 1 unaccounted-for slot
@@ -66,6 +73,16 @@ def create_items(self):
                 dupeItemPool = item_table.copy()
                 # Remove frequencies if necessary
                 if self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player].value != 5: # Not completely random locations
+                    # If we let frequencies stay in with progressive-frequencies, the progressive-frequency item
+                    # will be included 7 times. This is a massive flood of progressive-frequency items, so we
+                    # instead add progressive-frequency as its own item a smaller amount of times to prevent
+                    # flooding the duplicate item pool with them.
+                    if self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player].value == 4:
+                        for _ in range(2):
+                            # Progressives are not in item_pool, need to create faux item for duplicate item pool
+                            # This can still be filtered out later by duplicate_items setting
+                            dupeItemPool.append({ "name": "progressive-frequency", "progression": True }) # Progressive frequencies need to be included
+                    # Always remove non-progressive Frequency items
                     dupeItemPool = (itm for itm in dupeItemPool if "Frequency" not in itm["name"])
                 
                 # Remove progression or non-progression items if necessary
@@ -129,7 +146,7 @@ def collect_item(self, state, item, remove=False):
         return super(RaftWorld, self).collect_item(state, item, remove)
 
     def pre_fill(self):
-        if self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player] == 0:
+        if self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player] == 0: # Vanilla
             self.setLocationItem("Radio Tower Frequency to Vasagatan", "Vasagatan Frequency")
             self.setLocationItem("Vasagatan Frequency to Balboa", "Balboa Island Frequency")
             self.setLocationItem("Relay Station quest", "Caravan Island Frequency")
@@ -137,7 +154,7 @@ def pre_fill(self):
             self.setLocationItem("Tangaroa Frequency to Varuna Point", "Varuna Point Frequency")
             self.setLocationItem("Varuna Point Frequency to Temperance", "Temperance Frequency")
             self.setLocationItem("Temperance Frequency to Utopia", "Utopia Frequency")
-        elif self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player] == 1:
+        elif self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player] == 1: # Random on island
             self.setLocationItemFromRegion("RadioTower", "Vasagatan Frequency")
             self.setLocationItemFromRegion("Vasagatan", "Balboa Island Frequency")
             self.setLocationItemFromRegion("BalboaIsland", "Caravan Island Frequency")
@@ -173,9 +190,9 @@ def pre_fill(self):
                 else:
                     currentLocation = availableLocationList[0] # Utopia (only one left in list)
                 availableLocationList.remove(currentLocation)
-                if self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player] == 2:
+                if self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player] == 2: # Random island order
                     self.setLocationItem(locationToVanillaFrequencyLocationMap[previousLocation], locationToFrequencyItemMap[currentLocation])
-                elif self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player] == 3:
+                elif self.multiworld.island_frequency_locations[self.player] == 3: # Random on island random order
                     self.setLocationItemFromRegion(previousLocation, locationToFrequencyItemMap[currentLocation])
                 previousLocation = currentLocation
 
@@ -184,12 +201,14 @@ def pre_fill(self):
             RaftItem("Victory", ItemClassification.progression, None, player=self.player))
     
     def setLocationItem(self, location: str, itemName: str):
-        itemToUse = next(filter(lambda itm: itm.name == itemName, self.multiworld.itempool))
+        itemToUse = next(filter(lambda itm: itm.name == itemName, self.multiworld.raft_frequencyItemsPerPlayer[self.player]))
+        self.multiworld.raft_frequencyItemsPerPlayer[self.player].remove(itemToUse)
         self.multiworld.itempool.remove(itemToUse)
         self.multiworld.get_location(location, self.player).place_locked_item(itemToUse)
     
     def setLocationItemFromRegion(self, region: str, itemName: str):
-        itemToUse = next(filter(lambda itm: itm.name == itemName, self.multiworld.itempool))
+        itemToUse = next(filter(lambda itm: itm.name == itemName, self.multiworld.raft_frequencyItemsPerPlayer[self.player]))
+        self.multiworld.raft_frequencyItemsPerPlayer[self.player].remove(itemToUse)
         self.multiworld.itempool.remove(itemToUse)
         location = random.choice(list(loc for loc in location_table if loc["region"] == region))
         self.multiworld.get_location(location["name"], self.player).place_locked_item(itemToUse)