Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

The Plainsong model will not render with Verovio and EMA #10

Open
RichardFreedman opened this issue Sep 2, 2019 · 4 comments
Open

The Plainsong model will not render with Verovio and EMA #10

RichardFreedman opened this issue Sep 2, 2019 · 4 comments

Comments

@RichardFreedman
Copy link
Collaborator

The plainsong model renders OK in WorkView. But EMA citations of that work will not render. Note that plainsong pieces are encoded as one long measure, with a time signature.

See https://crimproject.org/relationships/240/

and the plainsong WorkView: https://crimproject.org/pieces/CRIM_Model_0022/
@rettinghaus
Copy link

Furthermore, plainsong should not contain encoded durations, and those senseless meter signatures should at least be hidden.

The encoding should look like the following. Notice that notes only need an oct and pname for complete rendering.

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<?xml-model href="https://music-encoding.org/schema/4.0.1/mei-CMN.rng" type="application/xml" schematypens="http://relaxng.org/ns/structure/1.0"?>
<?xml-model href="https://music-encoding.org/schema/4.0.1/mei-CMN.rng" type="application/xml" schematypens="http://purl.oclc.org/dsdl/schematron"?>
<mei meiversion="4.0.0" xml:id="m-1" xmlns="http://www.music-encoding.org/ns/mei">
 <meiHead xml:id="m-2">
  <fileDesc xml:id="m-3">
   <titleStmt>
    <title>
     Benedicta es
    </title>
    <respStmt>
     <persName auth="VIAF" auth.uri="http://viaf.org/viaf/27863792" role="composer">
      Attr. Balbulus Notker
     </persName>
     <persName role="editor">
      Vincent Besson
     </persName>
     <persName role="editor">
      Richard Freedman
     </persName>
    </respStmt>
   </titleStmt>
   <pubStmt>
    <publisher>
     Citations: The Renaissance Imitation Mass Project
    </publisher>
    <distributor>
     Centre d'Études Supérieures de la Renaissance
    </distributor>
    <distributor>
     Haverford CollegeVincent Besson
    </distributor>
    <distributor>
     Richard Freedman
    </distributor>
    <date isodate="2022-05-06"/>
    <availability>
     This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
    </availability>
   </pubStmt>
  </fileDesc>
  <encodingDesc xml:id="m-16">
   <appInfo xml:id="m-17">
    <application isodate="2017-6-1T17:33:00Z" version="8410" xml:id="sibelius">
     <name type="operating-system" xml:id="m-19">
      Mac OS X Mountain Lion
     </name>
    </application>
    <application type="plugin" version="2.1.0" xml:id="sibmei">
     <name xml:id="m-21">
      Sibelius to MEI Exporter (2.1.0)
     </name>
    </application>
    <application version="v1.0_beta" xml:id="app_2022126204946018">
     <name>
      mei30To40.xsl
     </name>
    </application>
    <application version="1.0.0">
     <name>
      add_metadata.py
     </name>
    </application>
   </appInfo>
  </encodingDesc>
  <workList xml:id="m-5">
   <work xml:id="m-6">
    <title xml:id="m-8">
     Benedicta es
    </title>
    <composer>
     <persName auth="VIAF" auth.uri="http://viaf.org/viaf/27863792" role="composer">
      Attr. Balbulus Notker
     </persName>
    </composer>
    <classification>
     <termList>
      <term>
       plainchant
      </term>
     </termList>
    </classification>
   </work>
  </workList>
  <manifestationList xml:id="manifestationList">
   <manifestation>
    <identifier type="RISM"/>
    <titleStmt>
     <title>
      Benedicta es
     </title>
    </titleStmt>
    <pubStmt>
     <publisher>
      <persName auth="VIAF" auth.uri="">
       Convent of St. Louis de Poissy
      </persName>
     </publisher>
     <date>
      late 14th century
     </date>
    </pubStmt>
    <physLoc>
     <repository>
      <corpName>
       Museum of Fine Arts
      </corpName>
      <settlement>
       Boston, MA
      </settlement>
     </repository>
     <identifier type="shelfmark">
      MS 80504
     </identifier>
    </physLoc>
   </manifestation>
  </manifestationList>
 </meiHead>
 <music xml:id="m-22">
  <body xml:id="m-23">
   <mdiv xml:id="m-24">
    <score xml:id="m-25">
     <scoreDef meter.count="4" meter.unit="4" meter.form="invis" xml:id="m-26">
      <staffGrp xml:id="m-27">
       <staffDef clef.dis="8" clef.dis.place="below" clef.line="2" clef.shape="G" key.sig="0" lines="5" n="1" xml:id="m-28">
       </staffDef>
      </staffGrp>
     </scoreDef>
     <section xml:id="m-31">
      <scoreDef meter.count="19" meter.unit="4" meter.form="invis" xml:id="m-1201"/>
      <measure label="1" metcon="false" n="1" right="invis" xml:id="m-32">
       <staff n="1" xml:id="m-34">
        <layer n="1" xml:id="m-35">
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-36">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-65">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-66">
            2. Tu
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-67">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-68">
            1.Be
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-37">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-69">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-70">
            ne
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-75">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-76">
            prea
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-38"/>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-39">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-71">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-72">
            dic
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-77">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-78">
            cla
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-40"/>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-41">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-73">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-74">
            ta
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-79">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-80">
            ra
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-42">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-81">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-82">
            es,
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-83">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-84">
            ma
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-43">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-85">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-86">
            ris,
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-87">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-88">
            cae
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="4" pname="c" xml:id="m-44">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-89">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-90">
            lo
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-93">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-94">
            ste
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-45">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-91">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-92">
            rum
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-95">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-96">
            la
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-46">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-97">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-98">
            re
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-103">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-104">
            vo
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-47">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-99">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-100">
            gi
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-105">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-106">
            ca
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-48">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-101">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-102">
            na,
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-107">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-108">
            ris,
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-49">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-109">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-110">
            et
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-111">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-112">
            quae
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-50">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-113">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-114">
            mun
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-117">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-118">
            so
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-51">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-115">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-116">
            di
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-119">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-120">
            lem
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-52">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-121">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-122">
            to
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-127">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-128">
            ju
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="f" xml:id="m-53">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-123">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-124">
            ti
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-129">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-130">
            sti
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="e" xml:id="m-54">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-125">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-126">
            us
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-131">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-132">
            ti
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="f" xml:id="m-55">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-133">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-134">
            a
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-135">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-136">
            Do
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-56">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-137">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-138">
            mi
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-141">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-142">
            pa
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-57">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-139">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-140">
            na
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-143">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-144">
            ris,
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-58">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-145">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-146">
            et
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-147">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-148">
            a
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-59">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-149">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-150">
            quo
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-151">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-152">
            ae
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-60">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-153">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-154">
            gris
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-163">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-164">
            il
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-61">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-155">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-156">
            me
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-165">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-166">
            lu
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="f" xml:id="m-62">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-157">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-158">
            di
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-167">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-168">
            mi
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-63">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-159">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-160">
            ci
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-169">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-170">
            na
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-64">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-161">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-162">
            na.
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-171">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-172">
            ris.
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
        </layer>
       </staff>
      </measure>
      <scoreDef meter.count="25" meter.unit="4" meter.form="invis" xml:id="m-1201"/>
      <measure metcon="false" n="2" right="invis" xml:id="m-173">
       <staff n="1" xml:id="m-175">
        <layer n="1" xml:id="m-176">
         <note oct="4" pname="c" xml:id="m-177">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-202">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-203">
            3. Te
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-212">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-213">
            4. Sanc
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-178">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-204">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-205">
            De
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-214">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-215">
            ti
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-179">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-206">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-207">
            us
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-216">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-217">
            fi
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-180">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-208">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-209">
            pa
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-218">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-219">
            ca
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-181">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-210">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-211">
            ter,
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-220">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-221">
            vit,
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="4" pname="c" xml:id="m-182">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-222">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-223">
            ut
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-224">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-225">
            sanc
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-183">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-226">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-227">
            tam
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-228">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-229">
            De
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-184">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-230">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-231">
            i
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-236">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-237">
            ser
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-185">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-232">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-233">
            ma
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-238">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-239">
            va
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-186">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-234">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-235">
            ter,
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-240">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-241">
            vit,
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-187">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-242">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-243">
            et
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-244">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-245">
            fi
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-188">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-246">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-247">
            e
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-250">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-251">
            mit
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-189">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-248">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-249">
            res
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-252">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-253">
            tens
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-190">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-254">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-255">
            et
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-256">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-257">
            sic
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="f" xml:id="m-191">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-258">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-259">
            ip
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-266">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-267">
            sa
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="e" xml:id="m-192">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-260">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-261">
            se
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-268">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-269">
            lu
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="f" xml:id="m-193">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-262">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-263">
            fra
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-270">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-271">
            ta
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-194">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-264">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-265">
            ter,
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-272">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-273">
            vit,
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-195">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-274">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-275">
            cu
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-278">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-279">
            A
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-196">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-276">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-277">
            jus
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-280">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-281">
            ve
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-197">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-282">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-283">
            e
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-286">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-287">
            ple
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-198">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-284">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-285">
            ras
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-288">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-289">
            na
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="f" xml:id="m-199">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-290">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-291">
            fi
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-296">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-297">
            gra
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-200">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-292">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-293">
            li
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-298">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-299">
            ti
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-201">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-294">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-295">
            a.
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-300">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-301">
            a.
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
        </layer>
       </staff>
      </measure>
      <scoreDef meter.count="32" meter.unit="4" meter.form="invis" xml:id="m-1201"/>
      <measure metcon="false" n="3" right="invis" xml:id="m-302">
       <staff n="1" xml:id="m-304">
        <layer n="1" xml:id="m-305">
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-306">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-338">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-339">
            5. Per
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-340">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-341">
            6. Nunc
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="4" pname="c" xml:id="m-307">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-342">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-343">
            il
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-346">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-347">
            ma
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="4" pname="c" xml:id="m-308">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-344">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-345">
            lud
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-348">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-349">
            ter
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="4" pname="c" xml:id="m-309">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-350">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-351">
            a
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-354">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-355">
            ex
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-310">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-352">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-353">
            ve
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-356">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-357">
            o
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-311">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-358">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-359">
            ra
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-360">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-361">
            pro
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-312">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-362">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-363">
            la
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-366">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-367">
            na
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-313">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-364">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-365">
            tum,
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-368">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-369">
            tum,
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-314">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-370">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-371">
            et
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-372">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-373">
            ut
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="4" pname="c" xml:id="m-315">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-374">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-375">
            tu
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-378">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-379">
            nos
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="4" pname="c" xml:id="m-316">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-376">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-377">
            um
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-380">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-381">
            trum
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="4" pname="c" xml:id="m-317">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-382">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-383">
            tol
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-386">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-387">
            res
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-318">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-384">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-385">
            lat
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-388">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-389">
            pon
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-319">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-390">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-391">
            sum
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-396">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-397">
            re
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-320">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-392">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-393">
            gra
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-398">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-399">
            a
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-321">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-394">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-395">
            tum,
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-400">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-401">
            tum,
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-322">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-402">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-403">
            et
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-404">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-405">
            et
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-323">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-406">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-407">
            ex
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-410">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-411">
            reg
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-324">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-408">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-409">
            te
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-412">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-413">
            num
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-325">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-414">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-415">
            det
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-416">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-417">
            ver
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="f" xml:id="m-326">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-418">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-419">
            bum
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-420">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-421">
            no
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="e" xml:id="m-327">
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-422">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-423">
            bis
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-424">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-425">
            in
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="f" xml:id="m-328">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-426">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-427">
            car
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-432">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-433">
            pa
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-329">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-428">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-429">
            na
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-434">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-435">
            ra
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-330">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-430">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-431">
            tum,
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-436">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-437">
            tum,
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-331">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-438">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-439">
            quo
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-440">
           <syl wordpos="i" xml:id="m-441">
            in
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="b" xml:id="m-332">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-442">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-443">
            sal
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-448">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-449">
            cae
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="a" xml:id="m-333">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-444">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-445">
            van
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-450">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-451">
            les
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-334">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-446">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-447">
            tur
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-452">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-453">
            ti
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="f" xml:id="m-335">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-454">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-455">
            om
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-460">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="i" xml:id="m-461">
            pa
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-336">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-456">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-457">
            ni
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-462">
           <syl con="d" wordpos="m" xml:id="m-463">
            tri
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
         <note oct="3" pname="g" xml:id="m-337">
          <verse n="1" xml:id="m-458">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-459">
            a.
           </syl>
          </verse>
          <verse n="2" xml:id="m-464">
           <syl wordpos="t" xml:id="m-465">
            a.
           </syl>
          </verse>
         </note>
        </layer>
       </staff>
      </measure>
     </section>
    </score>
   </mdiv>
  </body>
 </music>
</mei>

@RichardFreedman
Copy link
Collaborator Author

Thanks for the suggested encoding. You are quite correct that this would be the way to encode plainsong. The problem for us is that we need to use the EMA citation tool with all CRIM files (so that users can address and annotate specific notes). EMA will only work with scores encoded in measures. So the 'meaningless' time signatures are simply the count of notes in each phrase. You will see that the PDF files are not engraved in this way (with time signatures).

@rettinghaus
Copy link

As you can see it still has the measures. The encoding above will render like this:

image

@RichardFreedman
Copy link
Collaborator Author

That is helpful. We were not able to implement this kind of thing at the time we first launched things. Now the EMA references that involve these pieces already use the 'meaningless' measures. It's possible to correct these, but we are working on other things at the moment, so I will put this on a list! Thanks!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
2 participants
@RichardFreedman @rettinghaus