Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
211 lines (174 loc) · 9.18 KB

README.md

File metadata and controls

211 lines (174 loc) · 9.18 KB
Raw

Test results

Please see test.c.

Running make testdbg executes the program in gdb.

The test runs 7 iterations, each iteration allocating a total of 1 GB, writing a few bytes to it, and then deallocating it.

Breakpoints at lines 12, 29 and 32.

Test platform Termux Linux 4.19.157 aarch64 Android.

0th iteration:

  • at line 12: sbrk(0) = 0x555555a000
  • at line 29: sbrk(0) = 0x559555a0e0
  • at line 32: sbrk(0) = 0x559555a0e0

1st iteration:

  • at line 12: sbrk(0) = 0x555555a000
  • at line 29: sbrk(0) = 0x559555a0e0
  • at line 32: sbrk(0) = 0x559555a0e0

Subsequent iterations:

Similar to 1st iteration

Observations:

Difference in sbrk(0) in same iteration b/w lines 29 and 12 = 0x559555a0e0 - 0x555555a000 = 1 GB. This indicates the allocator is properly allocating blocks.

Difference in sbrk(0) in same iteration b/w lines 32 and 29 = 0x559555a0e0 - 0x559555a0e0 = 0 B. This indicates allocator is not updating brk unless the last allocated block is freed.

Difference in sbrk(0) b/w two iterations at line 12 of each iteration = 0x555555a000 - 0x555555a000 = 0 B. This indicates the allocator is properly deallocating blocks.

Conclusion:

Difference in sbrk(0) before and after run = 0 B.

Hence, allocator is functioning as expected.

Notes:

On testing in a Linux 5.10.147+ x86_64, difference in sbrk(0) before and after run = 132 KB

It was observed that this allocation happened before the first call to xmalloc.

Most likely this was allocated by libc as printf uses malloc and that in turn uses sbrk (see Test (no malloc) Results).

  • Address of sbrk(0) before run = 0x555555559000
  • Address of 1st allocation of 0th iteration = 0x55555557a000
  • Difference = 0x55555557a000 - 0x555555559000 = 132 KB

We still can conclude that deallocation is successful by inspecting pointers in gdb.

Test Fail Results

Please see test-fail.c. This test is designed to fail.

Running make test-fail-dbg executes the program in gdb.

brk init = 0x555555b000
libxalloc: aborted: buffer at '0x555559b050' overflowed

Program received signal SIGABRT, Aborted

The address 0x555559b050 is the address of the variable s1 (see test-fail.c:18).

It can be checked by running p s1 at frame of main from gdb.

Looking at the code at test-fail.c:23, note that we are indeed overflowing the buffer of s1 by 1 B.

As a result, memory is corrupted, and xmalloc at test-fail.c:26 fails.

Test (no malloc) Results

Please see test-no-malloc.c.

Running make test-no-malloc-dbg executes the program in gdb.

The idea is to modify test.c, replacing *alloc and free functions of libc with custom overrides. This is to prevent libc allocators from interfering with libxalloc.

The custom overrides provide the allocation dump.

It is observed that the difference in sbrk(0) at the end of execution is 0 B.

Observations:

Test platform Termux Linux 4.19.157 aarch64 Android:
  • First 48 B, 8 B and 48 B allocations are not by printf.
  • First 48 B allocation causes allocator initialization (see Allocator Initialization).
  • Calling malloc(0) (see test-no-malloc.c:105) doesn't do anything in this case.
  • Brk init is calculated at this point, before 1st printf.
  • Brk init is the ending address of initial 128 KB + 40 B bloc.
  • First printf causes allocation of 1024 B.
  • After every print, printf calls free(NULL) for some reason.
  • printf never frees the initial 1024 B.
  • Brk exit is calculated before 2nd last printf.
  • In the end, difference in sbrk(0) is 0 B.
  • Initial 128 KB + 40 B bloc is never freed.
Test platform Linux 5.10.147+ x86_64:
  • First 48 B, 8 B and 48 B allocations never happen.
  • So, malloc(0) causes allocator initialization in this case.
  • Otherwise, brk init will end up 128 KB + 40 B ahead of brk end.
  • Brk init is calculated at this point, before 1st printf.
  • Brk init is the ending address of initial 128 KB + 40 B bloc.
  • First printf causes allocation of 1024 B.
  • printf never calls free(NULL).
  • printf never frees the initial 1024 B.
  • Brk exit is calculated before 2nd last printf.
  • In the end, difference in sbrk(0) is 0 B.
  • Initial 128 KB + 40 B bloc is never freed.

Conclusion:

  • First printf allocates 1024 B.
  • libxalloc allocates 128 KB + 40 B to reduce syscalls.
  • printf never frees the 1024 B.
  • Extra occupied space at exit = 128 KB + 40 B.
  • This occupied space can be inspected via gdb.

References:

  • 1 GB = 1073741824 B
  • 256 MB = 268435456 B

Allocation dump:

Dump of make test-no-malloc-dbg.

Indented stuff is by the allocator, unindented stuff is by printf.

    malloc: ptr = '0x555555b640', size = 48 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x555555bcb0', size = 8 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x555555c2f8', size = 48 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x555555c968', size = 1024 B
brk init = 0x555557b028
    free: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B, freed = 0 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B
0: abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz
    free: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B, freed = 1073741824 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B
1: abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz
    free: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B, freed = 1073741824 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B
2: abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz
    free: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B, freed = 1073741824 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B
3: abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz
    free: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B, freed = 1073741824 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B
4: abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz
    free: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B, freed = 1073741824 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B
5: abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz
    free: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B, freed = 1073741824 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B
    malloc: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B
6: abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz
    free: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x555557b668', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x556557b690', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x557557b6b8', size = 268435456 B, freed = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x558557b6e0', size = 268435456 B, freed = 1073741824 B
brk exit = 0x555557b028
    free: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B, freed = 0 B
brk difference = 0 B
    free: ptr = '0x00', size = 0 B, freed = 0 B