diff --git a/worlds/sm64ex/Options.py b/worlds/sm64ex/Options.py
index 6cf233558ce2..9c428c99590e 100644
--- a/worlds/sm64ex/Options.py
+++ b/worlds/sm64ex/Options.py
@@ -3,10 +3,21 @@
 from Options import DefaultOnToggle, Range, Toggle, DeathLink, Choice, PerGameCommonOptions, OptionSet, OptionGroup
 from .Items import action_item_table
 
-class EnableCoinStars(DefaultOnToggle):
-    """Disable to Ignore 100 Coin Stars. You can still collect them, but they don't do anything.
-    Removes 15 locations from the pool."""
+class EnableCoinStars(Choice):
+    """
+    Determine logic for 100 Coin Stars.
+
+    Off - Removed from pool. You can still collect them, but they don't do anything.
+    Optimal for ignoring 100 Coin Stars entirely. Removes 15 locations from the pool.
+
+    On - Kept in pool, potentially randomized.
+
+    Vanilla - Kept in pool, but NOT randomized.
+    """
     display_name = "Enable 100 Coin Stars"
+    option_off = 0
+    option_on = 1
+    option_vanilla = 2
 
 
 class StrictCapRequirements(DefaultOnToggle):
diff --git a/worlds/sm64ex/__init__.py b/worlds/sm64ex/__init__.py
index 40c778ebe66c..afa67f233c69 100644
--- a/worlds/sm64ex/__init__.py
+++ b/worlds/sm64ex/__init__.py
@@ -104,7 +104,11 @@ def create_items(self):
         # 1Up Mushrooms
         self.multiworld.itempool += [self.create_item("1Up Mushroom") for i in range(0,self.filler_count)]
         # Power Stars
-        self.multiworld.itempool += [self.create_item("Power Star") for i in range(0,self.number_of_stars)]
+        star_range = self.number_of_stars
+        # Vanilla 100 Coin stars have to removed from the pool if other max star increasing options are active.
+        if self.options.enable_coin_stars == "vanilla":
+            star_range -= 15
+        self.multiworld.itempool += [self.create_item("Power Star") for i in range(0,star_range)]
         # Keys
         if (not self.options.progressive_keys):
             key1 = self.create_item("Basement Key")
@@ -166,6 +170,23 @@ def generate_basic(self):
             self.multiworld.get_location("Wing Mario Over the Rainbow 1Up Block", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("1Up Mushroom"))
             self.multiworld.get_location("Bowser in the Sky 1Up Block", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("1Up Mushroom"))
 
+        if (self.options.enable_coin_stars == "vanilla"):
+            self.multiworld.get_location("BoB: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("WF: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("JRB: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("CCM: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("BBH: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("HMC: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("LLL: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("SSL: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("DDD: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("SL: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("WDW: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("TTM: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("THI: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("TTC: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+            self.multiworld.get_location("RR: 100 Coins", self.player).place_locked_item(self.create_item("Power Star"))
+
     def get_filler_item_name(self) -> str:
         return "1Up Mushroom"