diff --git a/worlds/witness/options.py b/worlds/witness/options.py
index 2770d87ffef3..9b9c98304f39 100644
--- a/worlds/witness/options.py
+++ b/worlds/witness/options.py
@@ -210,7 +210,7 @@ class PanelHuntPostgame(Choice):
 
     display_name = "Force postgame in Panel Hunt"
 
-    option_off = 0
+    option_everything_is_eligible = 0
     option_disable_mountain_lasers_locations = 1
     option_disable_challenge_lasers_locations = 2
     option_disable_anything_locked_by_lasers = 3
diff --git a/worlds/witness/player_logic.py b/worlds/witness/player_logic.py
index 5a9c56bdf741..faf60eb748f4 100644
--- a/worlds/witness/player_logic.py
+++ b/worlds/witness/player_logic.py
@@ -424,7 +424,7 @@ def make_options_adjustments(self, world: "WitnessWorld") -> None:
             adjustment_linesets_in_order += self.handle_regular_postgame(world)
 
         # Exclude panels from the post-game if shuffle_postgame is false.
-        if not world.options.panel_hunt_postgame:
+        if world.options.panel_hunt_postgame:
             adjustment_linesets_in_order += self.handle_panelhunt_postgame(world)
 
         # Exclude Discards / Vaults